FIDE's Favorite Arbiter Would Like an Apology

She ran its world championships, then Wadim Rosenstein's treasury bid. Now FIDE says she abdicated.
On Saturday, FIDE said the arbiters at the Total Chess pilot in Budapest had "effectively abdicated their responsibility" to uphold the Laws of Chess. Their actions are going to the Arbiters' Commission and its Disciplinary Sub-Committee. A few hours later, the chief arbiter answered.
"I categorically reject," wrote Anastasia Sorokina, on behalf of "the ten highly qualified arbiters whose professional reputations FIDE has publicly called into question." She says her team followed the Laws of Chess and the regulations FIDE approved jointly with Norway Chess. Nobody appealed a decision. Nobody filed a complaint. And no one from FIDE called her: not during the event, and not before the statement went up. She demands that FIDE withdraw the allegation, publish a retraction through the same channels and apologize. The post passed 17,000 views by the evening.
The interesting part is who is fighting whom.

For most of the past decade, Sorokina has been about as close to FIDE as an arbiter can get. She was chief arbiter at the Women's World Championship in 2016, 2018 and 2023, and at the 2022 Candidates Tournament. In 2018 she was elected FIDE vice president. In 2024, at FIDE's own centenary awards, she was named Best Female Arbiter. Until this summer she chaired FIDE's Commission for Women's Chess. When she stepped down in July, then-president Arkady Dvorkovich thanked her for her dedication and the valuable work she had done for women's chess.
Then she changed teams. In August, Sorokina announced she was running alongside Wadim Rosenstein as FIDE treasurer. In September, she wrote that FIDE needed "meaningful change" and that Rosenstein as president was "the best path." Turlov won 110 votes to Rosenstein's 85. The Saturday statement on the arbiters is signed by Turlov and his deputy, Viswanathan Anand.
Nobody at FIDE has said this has anything to do with the election, and on paper it doesn't. FIDE referred Carlsen too, and he didn't campaign for anyone. But chess politics is a small room. In it, the arbiter FIDE used to hand its championships to, then gave an award, then thanked, is now the arbiter it is sending to a disciplinary committee. Rosenstein, for his part, spent Saturday standing with Carlsen. His treasurer spent it standing with the arbiters. Between them they've covered everyone FIDE blamed.
On the substance, Sorokina has one strong point and one weak one.
The strong one: FIDE says the arbiters "abdicated their responsibility" but doesn't say what they should have done. Under the Laws of Chess, an arbiter can't make a player sit down. When a player doesn't appear, the arbiter waits and then declares a forfeit. According to Sorokina and the tournament, that's what happened. Total Chess founder Kjell Madland said the same at the time: with the match decided, Carlsen didn't need to play. If FIDE thinks the arbiters should have thrown Carlsen out of the event, nothing in the regulations it co-signed says so. FIDE's own statement promises to "refine the rules on forfeits and their consequences" for 2027. That's an admission that the consequences weren't in the rules for 2026.
The weak one is Vladislav Artemiev. The forfeits against Assaubayeva came in a match that was already decided. FIDE says the three against Artemiev came while the outcomes were still open. That's harder to file under procedure. An arbiter who watches the world number one skip three live games in two days, applies the standard forfeit three times and never calls anyone may be following the letter of the rules. It's a strange thing to put on a CV for treasurer.
So now the dispute goes to the Arbiters' Commission. That's a FIDE commission, ruling on whether FIDE was right to criticize arbiters FIDE appointed, under rules FIDE approved, at an event FIDE endorsed. Sorokina has asked for the presumption of innocence. In chess, the usual remedy for a disputed decision is to appeal to the arbiter. Here the arbiter is the one appealing, and there's nobody above her but FIDE.



