
Carlsen Forfeits Game To Leave Total Chess In A Total Mess
The world number-one refused to play Bibisara Assaubayeva in Budapest, prompting condemnation from a senior FIDE official and accusations that the rules are being bent for the tournament's biggest star.
GM Magnus Carlsen has really set the cat among the pigeons now.
The world number-one, the greatest player in the history of the game, has sparked yet another extraordinary controversy at a world championship event, and this one is wild.
It comes after he refused to play a scheduled game against GM Bibisara Assaubayeva at the Total Chess World Championship Tour pilot in Budapest.
At first glance, it is not a good look to leave this top female player waiting, as this already iconic picture shows:
Don't you tell me the top women don't want to compete against the top men! 🤔 📷: chess24 https://t.co/CYawOgQIwf
— Women's Chess Coverage (@OnTheQueenside) November 17, 2026
But Carlsen's action, or inaction, was much worse than that. Almost immediately, it provoked a furious reaction from fellow grandmasters and accusations that the organisers are giving the 35-year-old preferential treatment because he is who he is.
It's an accusation we've heard before, frankly, but this time people were not holding back. Has Carlsen taken it too far this time?
OK, let's explain this
Carlsen forfeited Tuesday's Fast Classic encounter after apparently deciding there was no point in playing because he had already secured an unassailable lead on the first day of their knockout match. Again, this doesn't come across well.
However, the game was still scheduled to take place and, had it been played, would have counted towards both players' official classical ratings.
His refusal drew immediate ire from FIDE's chief executive adviser and piano-playing GM Emil Sutovsky, who described it as "pathetic unsportsmanlike conduct",
Carlsen's old adversary GM Hans Niemann, never one to miss a chance to have a nibble at his nemesis, also weighed in by accusing the organisers of allowing the Norwegian to disregard regulations that other players would be expected to follow. Niemann may even be on the money here too.
What can't be escaped here is that this incident is yet another embarrassment for the ambitious new competition, which arrived in Budapest promising to revolutionise elite chess but has spent much of its opening week defending its experimental format. Carlsen hasn't followed the script.
Carlsen: 'If the match is done, it's done'
Carlsen had, as expected, dominated the opening day of his match against Assaubayeva, winning three blitz games, drawing another and winning both rapid encounters to establish an 11.5–0.5 lead. With only eight points available in the remaining Fast Classic game, there was no possibility of Assaubayeva overturning the result.
Assaubayeva was left waiting awkwardly at the board when Carlsen approached the chief arbiter rather than taking his seat. After a lengthy discussion, the Norwegian left without playing, and his opponent was awarded an eight-point victory by forfeit.

Speaking to Norwegian broadcaster TV2, Carlsen defended his decision, arguing that there was no sporting justification for requiring players to contest a rated game once the day's result had been settled.
"There will be no classical game as I understood, the match is over. The only consequence of not showing up is that you will lose a totally useless game. I think that if you play a World Championship and it counts for points and such, I can understand.
"But this is not a show tournament - if the match is done, it's done. In the end, if you play games after, it shall not be rated because it's always been like that. And if they want to do things differently here... yeah. This is my decision on this topic."
So screw the tournament, then.

"Whether games could count even after the match was over was discussed and agreed upon in the technical meeting. If Carlsen was playing someone with a higher rating, he might have been more inclined to play," the American wrote on X.

OK, Carlsen's claiming it's dead rubber. He's not wrong.
But Total Chess's rules require players to contest four blitz games, two rapid games and one Fast Classic game on each knockout day, with the three formats contributing different amounts to the overall score. Although Carlsen had won Tuesday's leg, the two-day match itself was not over, with the players due to meet again on Wednesday.
The forfeit reduced Carlsen's winning margin for the day to 11.5–8.5, but it did not prevent him from claiming the first leg.
Niemann: 'All rules must be applied equally'
Niemann, whose bitter feud with Carlsen has repeatedly dominated chess headlines, was particularly to the point, claiming that the question of whether games should be played after a match result had been settled had already been discussed and agreed at the tournament's technical meeting.
Whether games could count even after the match was over was discussed and agreed upon in the technical meeting. If Carlsen was playing someone with a higher rating, he might have been more inclined to play. Nevertheless, if any other player forfeited a game, disrespecting the organiser and his opponent, they would have lost the match by forfeit. It’s incredibly dissapointing to see continued favouritism towards one player. Let’s not forget the jeans, and “Co World Champion” saga. All rules must be applied equally, regardless of the player. End of story.
— Hans Niemann (@HansMokeNiemann) November 17, 2026
"Nevertheless, if any other player forfeited a game, disrespecting the organiser and his opponent, they would have lost the match by forfeit. It's incredibly disappointing to see continued favouritism towards one player.
"Let's not forget the jeans and 'Co World Champion' saga. All rules must be applied equally, regardless of the player. End of story."
Niemann was referring to Carlsen's bust-up with FIDE over a dress-code violation at the 2024 World Rapid Championship and the subsequent decision to share the World Blitz Championship title with GM Ian Nepomniachtchi, two incidents that also raised eyebrows about the treatment of chess's biggest star.
His latest accusation is more serious because it challenges the organisers' interpretation and enforcement of their own regulations.
The organisers will need to clarify whether Carlsen's decision was OK under the rules and, if so, whether every other competitor would have been entitled to make the same choice.
'Pathetic unsportsmanlike conduct'
But Niemann is just another play, and one with an axe to grind. Sutovsky's remarks are a bigger deal: he is a FIDE official, and he was particularly blunt when assessing Carlsen's behaviour.
"Hard to comment on such a pathetic unsportsmanlike conduct," the senior FIDE official wrote on social media.
This is next-level stuff - perhaps years of frustration from the outspoken Israeli finally let out.
Hard to comment on such a pathetic unsporsmanlike conduct.
— Emilchess (@EmilSutovsky) November 17, 2026
Indian GM Srinath Narayanan, who captained India's team at the Chess Olympiad, also let rip, writing: "Dignity and courtesy took a fall long before the rating."
That stings!
English GM and commentator David Howell, a long-time friend of Carlsen who now lives in Norway, offered a typically more understated response:
"Congratulations to Bibisara Assaubayeva for beating Magnus Carlsen, that's all I can say!"
If you don't understand the subtext there, ask someone who's British to decode.
The rating question
And then there's the real issue. There is another reason why Carlsen's decision has attracted so much attention, and it concerns his increasingly precarious position at the top of the classical rating list.

The Norwegian has endured a disastrous opening week in Budapest, failing to win any of his ten Fast Classic group-stage games, drawing nine and losing one against GM Haik Martirosyan. Because Total Chess's new 45-minute time control counts towards official classical ratings, those results have cost Carlsen 21.8 live rating points and left him on 2801.2.
He is consequently in danger of falling below 2800 for the first time since 2009, while GM Fabiano Caruana has been closing the gap at the top of the rankings.
Assaubayeva's live classical rating was around 2540, meaning Carlsen would have risked losing further points even with a draw. By declining to play, he avoided exposing himself to that possibility.
Niemann plainly believes this influenced his decision, although Carlsen himself presented the refusal as a matter of principle rather than an attempt to protect his rating.
This drips with irony. Carlsen has been among the most enthusiastic supporters of Total Chess, a competition intended to provide an alternative to traditional classical chess, and designed with his blessing. Yet its new format has now left him facing the possibility of losing the world number-one ranking he has held for more than 15 years.
Another headache for Total Chess
For the organisers, the timing couldn't be worse. The Budapest pilot has already attracted criticism over its demanding schedule, complicated scoring system and decision to classify games played at 45 minutes plus a 30-second increment as classical chess.
Reigning U.S. Champion GM Wesley So has been among the most vocal critics, questioning the legitimacy of the Fast Classic time control and comparing the demanding knockout schedule to a military endurance test.
Now Carlsen, the competition's biggest attraction, has effectively rejected one of the central features of the format by refusing to play a game that he considered meaningless but which the organisers had scheduled as part of the day's competition.
Total Chess CEO Kjell Madland has acknowledged that the Budapest event is intended to test the format ahead of the full tour's launch in March 2027, while stressing that the regulations apply equally to all 24 competitors.
"The Budapest pilot is an important learning exercise for Total Chess," he said, adding that the organisers wanted to hear from players and arbiters before deciding whether refinements were necessary.
"We are not approaching this with a predetermined view that the rules need to change; rather, we want to ensure that we have tested the format thoroughly and are taking the best possible version of it into its inaugural season."
Remember, this is just a pilot!



