Magnus Carlsen Says He Was Tired. Nepomniachtchi Wants Him Expelled.

Carlsen explained his Budapest forfeits on Norwegian TV. The rest of the elite answered, mostly on X.
Magnus Carlsen has explained why he didn't show up. "If I'd been feeling great, I would have played," he told the Norwegian broadcaster TV 2. "But I feel... tired and fed up. I didn't feel like playing at all."
That was about the Fast Classic game against Vladislav Artemiev, one of three he forfeited in a match that, according to FIDE, was still open. On Saturday FIDE referred him to its Ethics and Disciplinary Commission. On the rating question, which is what most people suspected, Carlsen was franker earlier in the week: "I understand the point, but rating does matter somewhat." And: "Of course it's cynical, but we're playing for 17th place, so rating points and things like that matter."
Then came the bigger point, delivered two days before FIDE opens its World Championship in Geneva: "I think everyone else cares about the classical world championship. I don't." He said he has long been used to doing things "somewhat on my own terms," and that it "has become very clear" he would "rather be home than be here."
He also had a complaint of his own: "What annoys me the absolute most in the chess world is that people do not believe me on what I say."

The rest of the elite answered the way chess players usually do now: in short interviews and on X.
Fabiano Caruana, who finished third in Budapest, told ChessBase India: "I don't think it's good at all." His fix was simple: "I think you should just forfeit the match if you don't play." He also had an analogy: "To me, it's like in tennis someone decided to drop the 2nd set and come back for the 3rd set."

Ian Nepomniachtchi went furthest: "I think the player has to be expelled from the tournament."
Maxime Vachier-Lagrave started diplomatically. "I'm a bit sad that some of the players decided to make their own headlines," he said. Then he edited himself on X: "Correction: that a crybaby decided to make his own headlines."

Levon Aronian took the long view, and the strangest one. "This event did make me melancholic and sad, but people change and sometimes not for better," he wrote on X. "For people who are disappointed with Magnus Carlsen I want you to see his actions as a blessing for chess. New generation plays hard and shows their hunger."
So the tally from the top of the game is one call for expulsion, one rule change, one crybaby and one blessing. The arbiters, meanwhile, want an apology from FIDE.
The only player in the story who hasn't said anything is Bibisara Assaubayeva. She was the one waiting at the board.




